Into the Lion’s Den: Fierce Kindness and the Commitments Senior Teams Daren’t Name

Some years ago I was at a business event, the kind with black ties, flowing champagne and a lot of people keen to talk to the star guest. That star guest was a very successful property developer, and he’d heard what I do. So, standing in a circle of his people, his PR team and the event hosts, he started quizzing me about his senior leadership team.

His questions had a lot of performance in them. His team, he told me (and everyone listening), couldn’t be trusted to deliver if he wasn’t around. There was a knowing laugh from the circle. I thought there was a taste of snideness to his words, aimed at people some of whom weren’t there to answer back. And maybe aimed a little at me too, to see how I’d react.

So I asked him if this was how he ran his team sessions. Whether he made the same kind of half-joking digs there, without ever quite naming what was going on or offering anything that might turn it around. Then I told him that, in my experience, an underperforming senior team was very often a leadership issue. His leadership.

You could have heard a pin drop. He shook my hand, quite firmly, and moved on.

Why I Said It

I’d love to claim some clever tactic, but what was going on for me was much simpler than that. I actually liked this man. I liked his drive and his appetite for risk. I liked the way he’d clearly built something big by refusing to play safe. And I thought someone like that deserved to have a bit of that directness given back to him for a change, because those very qualities probably meant it hardly ever happened. The people around him were far more likely to laugh along.

I also knew perfectly well that even if I wasn’t shown the door of that glitzy event then and there, I might just be quietly left off the guest lists in future.

Fierce Kindness and The Lion’s Den

One of the principles I hold most strongly about coaching, and about working with people generally, is something I call Fierce Kindness. I wrote about it in The 9 Types of Difficult People as a dynamic principle; two qualities that pull against each other and have to be actively held in balance:

  • The fierce part is the willingness to tackle difficulty head-on, saying clearly and respectfully what you think and what you need, and holding a boundary.
  • The kind part is listening properly, understanding the other person’s point of view, and offering support.

Fierceness on its own can tip into confrontation, or at least be heard that way. Kindness on its own slides into leniency, and the problem is allowed to carry on.

The image I hold for it is the old story of the lion with a thorn in its paw. Someone has to walk into the den and pull it out. The lion is in pain, it’s dangerous, and it has no way of knowing whether you’ve come to help or to hurt. You go in anyway, because the thorn needs to come out.

This matters for coaches in particular. We ask our clients to take risks all the time, in service of their goals and their own development. Have the difficult conversation we urge them, try the new behaviour, say the thing you’ve been avoiding.

It’s all very well doing good coaching when you, the coach, are risking nothing. But part of the discipline has to be recognising the moments when you must take a risk yourself, for the sake of the person in front of you, even if it’s someone you’ve only just met at a party.

The Thorn in Most Senior Teams

What that star guest was describing is one of the most common things I hear from senior leaders. Decisions get made and then drift. Commitments made at the board table dissolve on the way back to the office. (I wrote about one reason for that, confusion over which team you’re actually on, in an earlier article linked below.) Initiatives are talked about with real energy and never reviewed. Everyone knows a promise wasn’t kept, but nobody says so.

Patrick Lencioni describes this as a cascade. Teams that avoid honest disagreement end up with artificial harmony. Artificial harmony produces commitment that is only skin-deep, because the conversation that would have produced real buy-in never happened. And you can’t hold someone to account for a commitment they never truly made.

In senior teams there’s an extra twist, which is status. Admitting that you haven’t delivered, or telling a peer that they haven’t, puts at risk a standing that people at this level have spent decades building. So the team develops a habit of leaving it unnamed.

The frustration doesn’t go away, though. It leaks out sideways: in the corridor, in the car park, in a comment to someone outside the team. Or, in our star guest’s case, as a joke at a party, told to an audience about people who mostly weren’t there.

That’s the thorn. And a leader grumbling about it is walking round the outside of the den.

What Changed

He rang me about a week later and asked if I’d work with him. An offer I couldn’t refuse.

What made the difference in the coaching turned out to be surprisingly simple. We opened up the team sessions to a direct conversation about what he felt the leadership team needed to deliver, asked out loud with the people who had to deliver it. Alongside that, he and the other members of the team started asking each other a second question …

… what do you need in order to do that?

Those two questions together are fierce kindness in practical form. The first is the fierce part: saying clearly what’s required, to the people who need to hear it, instead of to a circle of onlookers. The second is the kind part: listening properly, assuming people want to deliver, and offering the support to help them do it.

Asked on its own, the first question tends to turn into blame, which is where our star guest had got stuck. Asked on its own, the second becomes a comfortable conversation that changes nothing. Together they made commitments real, because people had said to each other what they’d do and what they’d need, and so they could be held to it.

For You and Your Team

If you’re on a senior team and you know a commitment has slipped but haven’t said so, is that frustrating for you; and where is that frustration coming out? And if you’re a leader who has ever said, even half-jokingly, that your team can’t be trusted to deliver without you, it’s worth asking where you’re saying it, and who you’re saying it to.

Fierce Kindness is a choice about a way of being, and it asks something of us. We might get it wrong. Someone might shake your hand a bit too firmly and walk away. But the thorn is there whether we go into the den or not, and the lion is still in pain.

My experience, over a long career, is that people are far more grateful to the person who walks in than you’d ever expect. Sometimes they even ring you a week later.

Further Reading

  1. Patrick Lencioni, The Five Dysfunctions of a Team (Jossey-Bass, 2002)
  2. The Team You’re Actually On
  3. The 9 Types of Difficult People

More Support and Resources

I coach leadership teams who sense they’re not yet working well enough together. My flagship programme The Shift is a development experience that helps leadership teams strengthen trust, alignment and how they function together. The result for the organisation is clearer decisions, stronger collective leadership, and better performance.

Why It’s Normal to Feel Like You’re Not Quite There as a Team

If you could mind-read a senior leadership team, maybe 30 minutes into a difficult exec meeting, one thing you’d likely hear them asking is: “What is wrong with us!?”

And if you kept listening, you’d hear each of them holding an inner-voice running commentary on everyone else. That one’s being annoying. That one isn’t paying attention. That one is slippery-shouldered, and that one is cryptic in what they say. That one is way off-piste on what matters. And that one is forever vaguely threatening to use some power they hold, whether it’s position, knowledge or relationships, against the rest of us. All of them thinking it at the same time, and each appearing somewhere on somebody else’s list.

If you could see them sitting around that board table at a tough point in their decision-making, you might notice them thinking: “Why is this still happening to us?”, or, “Why are we still not good at being a team?”

What nobody says out loud is that each of them is holding a private sense of being somehow inadequate at this, or of being on a team composed of people who so often just seem wrong. That their team muddles through, but is a poor outlier really. And because none of them says it, none of them finds out that everybody else is thinking it too.

The Mythical Team

The standard they are failing against is the mythical team that has this handled. Not one they have ever been on, or even seen. Most of them have left a previous team over exactly these kinds of issues, and joined this one hoping it would be different. Somewhere, though, surely there must be a team where it all works?

I’d like to hire one of those planes that pull a banner, or write in the sky, and have it say:

THIS IS NORMAL • EVERY TEAM FEELS LIKE THIS • THERE’S A REASON IT HAPPENS • YOU CAN DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT

Which would be quite a long banner.

But one thing you can easily present in a team development session is Tuckman’s model. You know this one – Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing. Put that up and all the HR people will sit back, happy that you’re not going to disrupt anything.

Back We Go

What I’ve watched happen over and over is teams arriving back where they started. A team that had got itself into something like Performing, humming along, finds itself in a Storm again. Arguing (or avoiding conflict), annoyed with each other, feeling like there’s something wrong with them, and each of them thinking they’re the only team like this.

Susan Wheelan’s later research, which builds directly on Tuckman, shows that this is what teams do. They go back to earlier stages when their issues (more about those later) are unresolved. And development happens in a one step forward, two steps backward kind of way.(1)

I like Tuckman because of what’s implicit in it, not because of what it was intended to do. What I like is that if it’s true that teams develop in those stages, then it also makes sense to me that teams would regress in those stages too. Wheelan found exactly that.

Which is why Tuckman and Wheelan are still worth talking about, as a kind of map that tells you where you are when you find yourself back there.

What Sends You Back

I have my own view of what the causes of those ‘issues’ might be. And why so much of what happens for senior leadership teams will be bumping them back down the development stages, straight into a storm. I think it’s a long list, but if I had to summarise them, it would be into three groups of stressors, clustered around:

  1. Team membership – who’s in, who does what, who liaises with whom, who controls what. A new CFO joins without any of the unspoken understanding of what is what: who defers to whom, which arguments are already finished. You can’t pick that up in an induction, however good the person. Your team will go back to the Stormingphase to resolve it
  2. Team goals and objectives – what’s the latest priority, what’s slipping, where is the agenda coming from, what’s driving the focus
  3. Team operating environment – all the usual PEST (Political, Economic, Social, Technological) stuff, plus the layer above the team, owners, investors, NEDs, plus the layer below including all their direct reports.

Phew!

Any and all of those types of change load the team up with issues they haven’t yet resolved and so, as Tuckman/Wheelan show us, there you are, back at the Storming stage.

It happens a lot more than you might think, because of a lot more causes. So much so, that I think we should regard it as a regular occurrence. You’re not a dysfunctional team. There’s nothing wrong with you. And you’re not abnormal.

But, you are likely to find yourselves quite often in a situation where the team isn’t flying along nicely, where everything is not humming away in functional harmony.

If you’re the kind of team who wants to do something about that, who wants to get to Performing faster, or know how to recognise and get out of Storming with greater regularity, I’ve got two more things to point you towards.

Deliberate Attention

First is that the senior leadership teams I see who are best at this kind of development, make a conscious choice to put at least part of their collective attention on to the issue of how well they are functioning as a team.

Most teams don’t do this, which is partly why they have that unconscious worry about being mediocre. But there are also good reasons why they don’t do it, including that it can be risky. If you want to know more about why that is and how to do your team development safely, take a look at this article of mine https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/why-senior-teams-avoid-conflict-how-everything-changes-nick-robinson-4mlce/

Persistence

Like everything worthwhile, the need to do this kind of team development work does not go away. It’s like going to the gym, eating healthily, staying married. The effort is day-to-day, repetition, not giving up and staying in the game.

Real-life persistence is messy. It involves tiredness, fear, frustration, annoyance, doubt. And above all, a small daily refusal to give up.

I have been coaching like this for a long time now. I have watched teams heading back into Tuckman’s Storm, helped them get past it, and then seen them go through it again when something else around them changes. It is the most ordinary thing in this work.

It will happen to your team, probably sooner than you expect.

What separates the teams who handle it from the ones who don’t, and who go on suffering for it, is not whether they end up back in the Storm. It is whether they can look at each other and say, here we are again, right, what do we need to sort out this time. And do it with sleeves rolled up and something close to enjoyment. That is the answer to the unspoken question, “What is wrong with us?” Nothing is. You’re a team, and this is what teams do.

Further Reading

  1. Susan Wheelan: Creating Effective Teams: A Guide for Members and Leaders (Sage)

More Support and Resources

I coach leadership teams who sense they’re not yet working well enough together. My flagship programme The Shift is a development experience that helps leadership teams strengthen trust, alignment and how they function together. The result for the organisation is clearer decisions, stronger collective leadership, and better performance.